DIY or Hire a Fencing Installer: Which Is Better Value?
Quick answer
DIY garden fence installation is almost always cheaper in pure cash terms because you only pay for materials. For a standard 6ft closeboard fence, expect to spend roughly £40–£70 per panel in materials versus £80–£150 per panel fitted by a professional. The real question is whether your time, tools and confidence with post-hole digging, concrete mixing and levelling are worth that saving.

DIY versus professional: what each option actually involves
The choice between DIY or professional garden fence installation comes down to three things: total cost, the quality of the finished fence, and how much of your weekend you are willing to sacrifice.
DIY installation means buying panels, posts, gravel boards, concrete and any fixings yourself, then doing all the groundwork, fitting and finishing. You keep full control over material choice and timing, but you carry every risk if a post leans or a arris rail splits a year later.
Hiring a fencing contractor means paying for labour, materials and often a guarantee on the workmanship. A decent installer will strip the old fence, dispose of it, set posts in concrete, hang panels square and leave the site tidy. You pay more, but you buy certainty.
For a fuller breakdown of what each route typically costs across the UK, the garden fencing installation cost UK guide covers typical prices for different fence types and garden sizes.
Cost comparison: DIY materials versus fitted prices
| Fence type | DIY material cost (per panel, approx.) | Professional fitted cost (per panel, approx.) | Typical saving from DIY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lap panel (closeboard) | £40–£60 | £80–£120 | £30–£70 per panel |
| Feather edge boards | £55–£80 | £100–£150 | £40–£70 per panel |
| Composite panels | £90–£140 | £150–£220 | £50–£90 per panel |
| Picket or decorative | £45–£75 | £90–£140 | £40–£70 per panel |
These figures assume a standard 6ft panel on concrete posts. Costs rise if the ground is sloping, rooted, or if you need to remove and dispose of an old fence. A garden fence types cost comparison across timber, concrete and composite explains where each material sits on the value ladder.
Pros and cons of DIY fence installation
Advantages
- Lower out-of-pocket cost, especially on longer runs where panel numbers add up.
- You choose every component, from post depth to the brand of concrete.
- Work at your own pace over several weekends if needed.
- Useful skill to learn for future garden projects.
Disadvantages
- You need a post-hole digger, spirit level, string lines, mixer and ideally a second pair of hands.
- Poorly set posts lean within a season, particularly on clay or waterlogged ground.
- No workmanship guarantee; any failure is your problem to fix.
- Disposing of old panels and concrete arris rails can cost £50–£150 at a tip if you cannot reuse them.
- A 20-panel boundary can take a competent DIYer two to three full weekends.
Pros and cons of hiring a fencing installer
Advantages
- Faster completion, often one to three days for an average garden.
- Professional finish with posts set plumb and panels level.
- Workmanship guarantee, typically 1–5 years.
- Waste removal and site cleanup included in most quotes.
- Installer handles tricky ground, slopes and boundary disputes.
Disadvantages
- Significantly higher total cost, particularly for long runs.
- You are dependent on the installer's diary; summer bookings fill quickly.
- Quality varies; a poor fencer can be worse than doing it yourself.
- You must verify credentials and insurance before work starts.
If you are leaning toward hiring, it is worth knowing how to compare garden fencing quotes so like-for-like prices are actually being compared.
When DIY is the better value choice
DIY tends to win when:
- The fence run is short, say under 10 panels, so the labour saving does not justify a professional call-out.
- The ground is flat, soft and free of tree roots or old concrete.
- You already own or can borrow the necessary tools.
- You are replacing panels on existing sound posts, which is a far simpler job.
- You are confident working with concrete and levelling over a reasonable distance.
When hiring a professional is the better value choice
A fencer usually pays for itself when:
- The boundary is long, say 15 panels or more, where mistakes become expensive.
- The ground is sloping, rocky, clay-heavy or waterlogged.
- You need closeboard or feather edge fencing, which requires precise arris rail spacing.
- Old concrete posts need removing and disposing of.
- You want a guaranteed finish and do not have several weekends to spare.
Before booking, take time to check a garden fencing installer for public liability insurance, references and a written quote.
Preparing your garden before installation
Whichever route you choose, some groundwork makes the job smoother and cheaper:
- Walk the boundary and confirm who is responsible for the fence; check your title deeds if unsure.
- Clear shrubs, planters and stored items from at least a metre either side of the line.
- Mark the exact boundary with string and canes so both you and the installer know where the posts will go.
- Check for underground services by contacting the relevant utility providers before digging.
- Decide on gate positions, panel heights and whether gravel boards are needed before ordering materials.
- If neighbours share the boundary, let them know the plan in advance, particularly if access through their garden is required.
You can browse local fencing contractors on Gumtree to see who is advertising in your area and request a few quotes.
Decision summary
Choose DIY if the run is short, the ground is kind, you have the tools, and you value saving cash over saving time. Choose a professional if the job is large, the ground is difficult, you want a guaranteed finish, or you simply do not have the weekends to spare. For most UK homeowners, the tipping point is around 10 to 12 panels: below that, DIY usually wins on value; above it, the risk and effort of doing it yourself start to outweigh the saving.
FAQ
Is DIY fence installation really cheaper than hiring a professional?
Yes, in pure cash terms. Materials for a standard lap panel fence typically cost £40–£70 per panel, whereas a fitted price is usually £80–£150 per panel. The saving narrows once you factor in tool hire, waste disposal and your own time.
How long does it take to install a garden fence yourself?
A competent DIYer can fit 6 to 8 panels in a full day on straightforward ground. A typical semi-detached garden boundary of 15 to 20 panels usually takes two to three weekends, including digging post holes, mixing concrete and fitting.
Do I need planning permission for a new garden fence?
In most cases no, but fences over 2 metres high, or over 1 metre high next to a highway, usually require planning permission in England. Rules differ slightly in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, so check with your local council if you want anything taller than standard 6ft panels.
What should I look for in a fencing contractor's quote?
A good quote should itemise materials, labour, waste removal, the type and depth of posts, concrete specification, and any guarantee on workmanship. Avoid quotes that are vague about post depth or do not confirm who is disposing of the old fence.
Can I replace fence panels myself but keep the existing posts?
Yes, if the posts are sound, plumb and firmly set. This is one of the most cost-effective DIY fencing jobs and can usually be done in a day for a standard garden. Check that the arris rails are still solid before ordering new panels.
